Executive Summary
The Story So Far
Why This Matters
Who Thinks What?
European Economy Commissioner Valdis Dombrovskis stated on Friday that financial guarantees provided by EU member states for a proposed €140 billion ($162 billion) loan to Ukraine, underpinned by frozen Russian assets, should not count towards their national deficit and debt targets. The loan aims to cover Ukraine’s reparation needs, with repayment contingent on Russia providing reparations for damages incurred during the war.
Loan Guarantees and Fiscal Rules
The European Commission’s plan involves using immobilized Russian assets to secure the substantial loan to Ukraine. EU finance ministers discussed the proposal on Friday, where concerns regarding the guarantees were raised by Italy’s Giancarlo Giorgetti and other ministers.
Dombrovskis indicated that, under the proposed mechanism where the EU retains Russian assets until reparations are paid, the guarantees are not expected to be called upon. However, the EU’s statistics agency, Eurostat, would need to officially confirm that these guarantees do not impact member states’ deficit and debt levels once a definitive plan is established.
Sanctions and International Cooperation
The Commissioner also revealed that the Commission is exploring methods to prevent individual or a small group of EU members from blocking the renewal of sanctions against Russia, which currently require unanimous approval.
Dombrovskis cited an International Monetary Fund (IMF) estimate that Ukraine faces a $60 billion financing gap for 2026 and 2027, excluding military aid. Support for Ukraine is slated for discussion among G7 ministers at the upcoming World Bank and IMF annual meetings in Washington.
While the EU is not seeking guarantees for its loan from other G7 members, it is encouraging them to implement similar mechanisms for Russian assets frozen within their jurisdictions. Britain and Canada have reportedly expressed interest in adopting a model similar to the European approach.
Frozen Russian Assets
The Russian central bank has confirmed that approximately $300-350 billion worth of its assets are frozen in Western countries. The majority of these assets are located in Europe, with many having matured and now held as cash by the Belgian securities repository Euroclear.
Belgium has previously indicated that other EU member states must share the financial risk associated with providing the loan to Ukraine.
Key Takeaways
The EU is advancing a plan to leverage frozen Russian assets for a significant loan to Ukraine, with discussions focusing on ensuring these financial commitments do not adversely affect member states’ fiscal targets. Concurrently, the EU is addressing the unanimity requirement for sanctions and seeking international alignment on using frozen assets to support Ukraine’s recovery.