Executive Summary
- Incident: Police are investigating a burglary and confirmed arson at Calvary Church in Lake Havasu City.
- Person of Interest: Authorities are seeking 49-year-old Keith Gensamer in connection with the crime.
- Vehicle Description: The subject operates a silver or gray Toyota Tacoma with New Mexico plate BYXJ35.
- Public Warning: Gensamer is considered armed and dangerous; the public is urged not to approach him.
Lake Havasu City police are actively searching for a person of interest in connection with a burglary and arson reported at Calvary Church early Sunday morning. According to the Lake Havasu City Police Department, dispatchers received reports of a burglary and fire alarm at the facility, located at 3100 Sweetwater Avenue, at approximately 1:30 a.m. on November 30, 2025.
Upon arrival at the scene, officers reportedly observed signs of forced entry and discovered an active fire inside the structure. Following the suppression of the fire by the Lake Havasu City Fire Department, investigators from both agencies located substantial evidence indicating the incident was an act of arson.
Authorities have identified 49-year-old Keith Gensamer as a person of interest in the investigation. Law enforcement officials state that surveillance footage captured an individual, believed to be Gensamer, wearing a red hooded sweatshirt and jeans at the time of the incident. He was observed driving a silver or gray Toyota Tacoma pickup truck bearing New Mexico license plate BYXJ35.
Investigators noted that Gensamer’s vehicle was recently seen towing a travel trailer, and intelligence suggests he may be residing in the desert area south of Lake Havasu City. Police have issued a warning to the public that the individual should be considered armed and dangerous and should not be approached.
Public Safety Alert
The designation of the subject as armed and dangerous signifies a heightened threat level for the community, particularly for residents and recreational users of the desert areas south of Lake Havasu City. This alert necessitates strict adherence to safety protocols by the public, urging immediate contact with law enforcement rather than engagement. It is important to note that while Keith Gensamer has been identified as a person of interest in this investigation, all individuals are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.
