Executive Summary
- Authorities are offering a $50,000 reward for information on the 2001 murder of Nancy Smith.
- Smith was found stabbed to death in her New Windsor home after missing work.
- The FBI, New York State Police, and New Windsor Police are collaborating on the case.
- Investigators are utilizing advanced DNA testing and forensic tools to generate leads.
Federal, state, and local authorities have announced a combined $50,000 reward for information leading to an arrest and conviction in the unresolved 2001 murder of Nancy Smith in New Windsor, New York. The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), New York State Police, and the New Windsor Police Department are coordinating efforts to generate new leads as the 24th anniversary of the homicide approaches.
Smith, 32, was discovered deceased inside her residence on Provost Drive on December 5, 2001. According to the New Windsor Police Department, the discovery was made by her parents, who went to check on her after she failed to report for her scheduled shift at Horton Hospital in Middletown. Upon entering the home, they found Smith on the living room floor. Investigators subsequently determined that Smith had sustained multiple stab wounds in what officials described as a vicious attack.
Authorities stated that the increased reward consists of $35,000 from local and state funds, with an additional $15,000 contributed by the FBI. Law enforcement officials noted that the investigation remains active, with agencies utilizing advanced DNA testing and modern forensic tools to re-examine evidence collected over two decades ago. Detective Kevin Moore of the New Windsor Police Department and the FBI’s New York Field Office are the primary points of contact for any individuals holding information relevant to the case.
Investigative Outlook
The strategic involvement of federal resources and the application of modern forensic technology highlight a renewed commitment to resolving long-standing violent crimes in the region. By significantly increasing the financial incentive, investigators aim to encourage witnesses who may have previously withheld information to come forward. The reliance on advanced DNA profiling suggests that physical evidence remains central to the prosecution strategy, potentially bridging the gap created by the passage of time. As the investigation proceeds, law enforcement officials continue to seek a suspect to hold accountable for this capital offense.
