Executive Summary
The Story So Far
Why This Matters
Who Thinks What?
U.S. energy giant ExxonMobil has warned it may be forced to cease operations in the European Union if the bloc does not significantly amend its Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD). CEO Darren Woods stated on Monday that the law, which demands climate transition plans aligned with the Paris Agreement across global operations and carries potential fines of 5% of global revenue, is “technically unfeasible.” This stance is echoed by Qatar, a major gas producer, which has reissued threats to halt liquefied natural gas (LNG) supplies to Europe over the same legislation.
ExxonMobil’s Concerns Over Regulatory Scope
Speaking in Abu Dhabi, Mr. Woods outlined his concerns that the directive’s requirements extend beyond European operations, mandating climate plans for all of ExxonMobil’s global business irrespective of its connection to Europe. He described this as an “overreach” that would make it “impossible” for the company to continue operating successfully within the EU. The CSDDD aims to hold companies accountable for human rights and environmental risks throughout their supply chains.
ExxonMobil is actively lobbying against the directive, with Mr. Woods warning of “disastrous consequences” if it is adopted in its current form. While European lawmakers have engaged with energy producers, he noted that this has not led to substantial changes, but rather “muddling the language” which he believes increases room for interpretation and exposure.
Mr. Woods also criticized the broader economic environment, stating that the EU is already an “overregulated economy” that is “de-industrialising” and “suffocating economic growth.” He argued that the new directive would further impede economic development.
Qatar Echoes Objections on Energy Supply
Qatar’s energy minister, Saad al-Kaabi, who is also CEO of QatarEnergy, reinforced similar objections, stating that his country cannot meet the directive’s net-zero requirements. He reiterated a threat to halt LNG supplies to Europe if the law is not changed or cancelled. Qatar currently supplies between 12% and 14% of Europe’s LNG imports since Russia’s 2022 invasion of Ukraine.
Both Qatar and the United States previously urged European heads of state last month to reconsider the law, arguing it jeopardizes Europe’s access to reliable and affordable energy. Mr. al-Kaabi emphasized Europe’s reliance on gas from various global sources, including Qatar and the U.S., urging serious consideration of the directive’s impact.
Upcoming EU Decision
The European Parliament agreed last month to further negotiate changes to the law, with the EU aiming to approve final amendments by the end of the year. Energy companies, including ExxonMobil, have called for the complete withdrawal of the policy, arguing it would lead to businesses relocating away from Europe.
