The tragic incident involving the death of a 43-year-old woman in Key Largo has shed light on a troubling sequence of events. The woman’s body was discovered under a water heater in a resort hotel room two days after her death. The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office has charged 33-year-old Dylan Lamb, a convicted felon from Key Largo, with murder related to this case. He reportedly met the victim, Nadyne Marie Tillman, through a website associated with prostitution.
Authorities were alerted to the situation at the Amoray Beach Resort following reports of Tillman being missing. Friends and family noted her unusual silence and lack of response to messages. The investigation revealed Tillman had communicated with an associate about meeting someone from a non-dating website at the resort. Her last messages indicated she was at the hotel waiting for a response from the individual she intended to meet.
Hotel staff informed deputies of suspicious behavior involving Lamb, who had booked a room using his mother’s phone number. Reports disclosed that Lamb refused to change rooms when requested by the hotel’s management. After he checked out, cleaning staff found trash bags filled with stained linens consistent with blood and other substances. These were discarded before their significance was realized.
Deputies located Tillman’s body concealed under the water heater, exhibiting severe signs of trauma, including facial injuries. Lamb, who was on probation for a grand theft auto conviction, was apprehended after being contacted by his probation officer. At the time of his arrest, he possessed Tillman’s credit card.
Lamb claimed he met Tillman through the website ListCrawler and agreed to pay her for sex. He alleged that she attempted to leave without fulfilling their agreement, leading to a physical altercation. Lamb asserted he only struck Tillman once, but her injuries suggested otherwise. In a state of panic, Lamb reportedly attempted to clean the scene and hide the body. He disposed of evidence in trash bags, failing to contact authorities due to fear of repercussions.
Lamb faces several charges, including second-degree murder, false imprisonment, destruction of evidence, and soliciting prostitution. This case marks a troubling pattern, as Lamb was previously charged with battery in a separate incident involving another woman in November 2022. During that event, he allegedly assaulted the woman after a disagreement, resulting in serious injuries.
The legal proceedings for Lamb continue with scheduled court appearances, including an upcoming arraignment hearing. He remains held without bond at the Key West jail facility.
Understanding the Impact
- This incident raises concerns about safety within the hospitality industry, prompting discussions on enhancing security measures and staff training to identify suspicious activities.
- The case highlights the dangers associated with online transactions and meetings arranged through non-dating websites, underscoring the importance of exercising caution.
- Community awareness has increased regarding the potential risks posed by individuals with prior criminal records, influencing local perceptions of safety and trust.
- The legal outcomes of this case may affect public confidence in the judicial system’s ability to address violence and protect vulnerable individuals.
- Support services and resources for victims of violence and abuse might see increased demand as awareness of such incidents rises within the community.