In an ongoing legal case surrounding a fatal accident, lawyers representing the driver charged with the deaths of NHL player Johnny Gaudreau and his brother, Matthew, are preparing to present their arguments in court. The defense team plans to claim that the brothers contributed to the crash by cycling under the influence of alcohol. The brothers reportedly had blood-alcohol levels of .129 or higher, exceeding New Jersey’s legal limit of .08. They hope to reduce or dismiss the charges of manslaughter and vehicular homicide against the driver, Sean Higgins.
Salem County prosecutors, however, emphasize that New Jersey law does not prohibit cycling while intoxicated. Witness testimonies indicate that the Gaudreaus were riding single-file along the edge of a rural road, not swerving into traffic. Prosecutors argue that Higgins, allegedly impaired by alcohol and driven by road rage, collided with the brothers. According to Assistant Prosecutor Michael Mestern, multiple witnesses observed Higgins speeding and illegally overtaking another vehicle before striking the cyclists, who were riding with the traffic flow.
The tragic incident occurred while the Gaudreaus were cycling near their hometown in southern New Jersey on August 29, the day before their sister’s wedding. Both brothers had families, and Johnny Gaudreau’s widow recently gave birth to their third child. Known as “Johnny Hockey,” Gaudreau had a decade-long career in the NHL, most recently with the Columbus Blue Jackets.
Sean Higgins, a 44-year-old from Woodstown, New Jersey, faces charges of aggravated manslaughter, reckless vehicular homicide, evidence tampering, and fleeing the scene. A combat veteran and father of two, Higgins allegedly admitted to drinking while driving after a distressing phone call with his mother. If convicted, he could face up to 70 years in prison, although his legal team has turned down a plea deal offering a 35-year sentence.
The defense is also seeking to scrutinize the laboratory methods used in testing, asserting that their client deserves a fair and thorough presentation of charges. The court hearing is scheduled before Superior Court Judge Michael Silvanio, whose immediate ruling remains uncertain.
The Bottom Line
This case underscores the complexities of legal responsibility and intoxication in vehicular accidents. For the local community, the tragedy has been a poignant reminder of road safety and the severe consequences of driving under the influence. It raises questions about the adequacy of current traffic laws and highlights the emotional and legal challenges faced by the families involved.
For residents and legislators in New Jersey, the proceedings could prompt discussions on whether additional laws are needed to address cycling under the influence. The case may also influence public attitudes towards road safety and the legal system’s handling of cases involving alcohol consumption and vehicle-related fatalities.