Economy Candy, a renowned confectionery store, is experiencing significant challenges due to the recent tariffs imposed by President Donald Trump. Located on New York’s Lower East Side, the shop boasts an extensive array of sweets from around the globe, including gummies from Germany, lollipops from Spain, and exotic chocolates from Japan. This historic shop, managed by Mitchell Cohen, has over 2,000 items, most of which are affected by these tariffs.
The tariffs, impacting various sectors of the U.S. economy, have reached even small businesses like Economy Candy. Cohen had begun to see a decrease in inflation-driven price hikes from suppliers when the new tariff threats emerged. Committed to keeping the store affordable, he now faces potential price increases in the coming months, posing a challenge to maintaining competitive pricing.
Economy Candy transports visitors back in time with its nostalgic atmosphere, featuring a vintage sign, a green-and-white striped awning, and bins filled with classic candies like Smarties and Lemonheads. Despite being a small player within the $54 billion candy industry, it already contends with rising cocoa and ingredient prices, further compounded by the tariffs.
According to Consumer Price Index data, candy and gum prices have risen significantly over the years. In fact, pricing has become the most decisive factor for consumers when purchasing candy. Approximately one-third of Economy Candy’s products are imported, with tariffs now impacting items like Pistachio Snickers from India and passion fruit mousse Snickers from Portugal. Even American-made Snickers are not exempt, as their ingredients come from all over the world, including chocolate from Guyana and peanuts from Argentina.
The tariffs affect all candies, including those domestically produced, such as Nerds and Sugar Babies. Cohen, who took over the business from his parents, emphasizes the importance of affordability, yet acknowledges the financial strain on small businesses like his due to increased costs.
Founded during the Great Depression, the store initially focused on shoe and hat repairs but transitioned to candy sales as economic conditions changed. Despite facing challenges like the aftermath of the Sept. 11 attacks and the pandemic, which necessitated a shift to online sales, Economy Candy adapted. However, the current tariff situation presents new obstacles that Cohen fears may impede further adaptation, especially concerning international sales.
The tariffs could elevate the average U.S. tariff rate to 25%, the highest in over a century. Despite assertions that these measures would benefit the country, Cohen remains skeptical of their positive impact on his business, which relies heavily on international goods.
As Cohen received news of a 5% surcharge from a French supplier due to the tariffs, he maintained a positive outlook, determined to keep Economy Candy a joyful destination for customers.
The Tangible Impact
- Cost Increases: The tariffs are likely to lead to higher prices for imported goods, affecting consumers’ purchasing power and small businesses’ ability to maintain competitive pricing.
- Supply Chain Disruptions: As many products, even those manufactured in the U.S., rely on international ingredients, the tariffs complicate supply chains, potentially causing product shortages and delays.
- Impact on Small Businesses: Small retailers like Economy Candy face significant financial pressure from increased costs, threatening their ability to sustain operations and offer affordable products.
- Economic Shifts: The potential for higher average tariff rates may contribute to broader economic instability, affecting various industries and consumer confidence.
- Cultural and Consumer Choices: With tariffs impacting imported goods, consumers may have limited access to international products, influencing cultural diversity and purchasing options.
