Executive Summary
- Noah Shaffer, 26, is charged with first-degree robbery regarding a 2025 incident involving a NY Jets player.
- Police allege Shaffer and three masked accomplices ambushed the victim in his driveway using a vehicle with fake plates.
- Electronic evidence was used to link the suspect to the crime scene in Morristown.
- Shaffer is currently detained on unrelated charges and awaits a March 2 court hearing.
A 26-year-old New Jersey man has been charged with first-degree robbery in connection with an armed ambush of a New York Jets player outside his Morristown home in 2025, according to the Morris County Prosecutor’s Office. Authorities identified the suspect as Noah Shaffer of Paterson, who is accused of participating in the gunpoint robbery alongside three other masked individuals.
The incident occurred on February 15, 2025, in the Windmill Pond section of Morristown. According to police reports, the professional football player, whose identity has been withheld, had just returned from New York City and pulled into his driveway when an SUV blocked his vehicle. Investigators state that four masked men exited a Volkswagen Taos displaying fictitious license plates, brandishing handguns.
Police allege the assailants pointed firearms at the victim and demanded his possessions. The suspects reportedly stole the player’s watch and wallet, as well as cash from the driver, before fleeing the scene in the SUV. Morris County First Assistant Prosecutor Maggie Calderwood confirmed that investigators utilized electronic evidence to link Shaffer to the crime scene.
Shaffer faces two counts of first-degree robbery and second-degree conspiracy to commit armed robbery. Court records indicate he was already in custody at the Bergen County Jail regarding an unrelated criminal case originating in Passaic County. Authorities noted that Shaffer was charged with the robbery offenses on January 15 and is scheduled to appear in Morris County Superior Court for a hearing on March 2.
Investigative Outlook
While Shaffer is in custody, the investigation remains active as law enforcement officials continue to search for the other individuals involved in the ambush. The Morris County Prosecutor’s Office Major Crimes Unit is soliciting information from the public to identify the remaining suspects. As this case moves to the judicial phase, it is important to note that all individuals, including Shaffer, are presumed innocent of all charges until proven guilty in a court of law.
