Nestled in the San Carlos Park neighborhood of Fort Myers, San Matteo Italian Restaurant & Bar is drawing attention for its blend of authentic Italian cuisine and modern dining elements. Helmed by Executive Chef Giuseppe Manco and his wife Eleonora Calvacchi, the restaurant promises guests a genuine taste of Italy without the travel fatigue.
The culinary philosophy at San Matteo is a harmonious fusion of traditional Italian dishes with a contemporary twist. The menu features highly praised Neapolitan-style pizzas and burgers, and meticulously crafted dry-aged meats. Notably, meat used in the restaurant is sourced from the revered Pat La Frieda, ensuring quality and flavor in every dish.
San Matteo’s extensive menu is a highlight, offering a wide array of dishes that accommodate various tastes. Popular options include the classic Margherita pizza topped with tomato sauce, mozzarella, and fresh basil, alongside other inventive varieties like the Nutella pizza – a sweet indulgence loved by many. Other noteworthy items are their spaghetti dishes, rich with San Marzano DOP sauce, and their risottos brimming with seafood treasures like octopus and scallops.
The restaurant experience is complemented by an impressive selection of wines, both imported and domestic, housed in a beautiful wine cellar. This emphasis on fine wine makes it a premier spot for connoisseurs and those simply looking to enjoy a quality glass with their meal. Furthermore, guests can enjoy their meal on the expansive outdoor patio, which offers picturesque al fresco dining year-round.
Reviews of San Matteo often speak to the venue’s vibrant atmosphere with live music enhancing the dining experience. Though praised for its food and service, some diners noted variability in the appeal of certain dishes. Guests highlighted the attentive service, particularly thanking staff like server Jordan for their exceptional hospitality.
Diners generally rate San Matteo highly, with a commendable average score. While some guests reported slow service or issues with reservations, the majority found the dining experience delightful and worth revisiting. The restaurant’s management is responsive to feedback, often addressing concerns raised in reviews to improve their offerings.
San Matteo Italian Restaurant & Bar stands out as a beacon of Italian culinary art in Fort Myers. Whether patrons are seeking a memorable evening with live music and fine wines or looking to indulge in meticulously prepared dishes, the restaurant caters to a broad spectrum of tastes. While some areas may need fine-tuning, the overall experience at San Matteo is of high quality, making it a favored destination for Italian cuisine enthusiasts in the region.
Directions to San Matteo Italian Restaurant & Bar
Source: Opentable
