Located in the heart of Fort Myers, San Matteo Italian Restaurant & Bar offers an authentic taste of Italy, crafted by Executive Chef Giuseppe Manco and his dedicated team. This establishment has quickly become a local favorite, known for its traditional Italian dishes with a modern flair.
San Matteo presents a delightful fusion of classic and contemporary Italian cuisine. Chef Giuseppe and his wife, Eleonora Calvacchi, have created an exquisite menu that includes award-winning Neapolitan-style pizzas and beloved Italian-American classics. Diners can savor the rich flavors of Italy through the restaurant’s pasta dishes, allowing them to indulge in authentic tastes without leaving town.
The inviting ambiance enhances the overall dining experience. With a seating capacity of 270, the restaurant boasts a modern and comfortable environment, complemented by an impressive wine cellar featuring both imported and domestic selections. This focus on quality wine greatly enriches the dining experience, making it a highlight of the venue.
For those who prefer to dine outdoors, San Matteo offers a spacious patio, ideal for year-round dining. This versatility makes the restaurant suitable for various events, from family gatherings to corporate functions. Its vibrant yet relaxed atmosphere ensures guests feel welcomed and engaged throughout their visit.
The diverse menu caters to every taste, featuring popular items such as the Margherita and Napoli pizzas, which receive rave reviews for their authenticity and flavor. Starters like Bruschetta al Pomodoro and Mozzarella Fritta come highly recommended, while the main course selection includes authentic pasta dishes like Bucatini Carbonara and seafood options such as Herb Roasted Salmon.
Though the restaurant garners praise, some reviews indicate inconsistencies in service. While many diners commend the attentive staff and exceptional food, others have reported issues with delays and reservation mishaps, affecting their overall experience. Complaints about long wait times and occasional reservation mismanagement have emerged from a few patrons.
On the brighter side, many guests appreciate the lively atmosphere, often enhanced by live music. The restaurant maintains a respectable overall rating of 4.5 stars, reflecting its popularity despite occasional service challenges.
The restaurant also boasts an impressive Google rating of 4.2 out of 5, earning positive feedback from patrons who enjoy its flavorful dishes and attentive service.
In summary, San Matteo Italian Restaurant & Bar offers a diverse menu of authentic Italian cuisine in a warm and inviting environment. While service experiences may vary, the delicious dishes and elegant ambiance solidify its reputation as a must-visit dining destination.
Directions to San Matteo Italian Restaurant & Bar
Source: Opentable & Google Business Profile
