Key Biscayne, a tranquil waterfront village near Miami, offers a vibrant dining scene that rivals its scenic beauty. Visitors and locals alike can indulge in diverse culinary experiences, each providing a distinct flavor of island life. The following guide takes you through some of the best restaurants that Key Biscayne has to offer, ensuring an unforgettable dining adventure away from the typical tourist spots.
At the heart of Key Biscayne’s dining landscape is Vinya Wine & Market, a wine bar and restaurant that has become a local favorite since its opening in 2021. With a wine program led by sommelier Allegra Angelo, Vinya offers themed tasting events and a menu of contemporary American dishes like steamed mussels and braised short rib. Despite its focus on wine, the establishment also serves skillfully mixed cocktails.
Flour & Weirdoughs stands out with its innovative pastry creations. This bakery takes traditional items and adds unique twists, such as topped Danish with smoked salmon and pear pizzas with gorgonzola. Its adventurous use of ingredients like brisket in croissants makes it a must-visit for those seeking unusual yet delightful flavors.
Rusty Pelican offers a classic Miami dining experience with its prime waterfront location and seafood-centric menu. Popular for celebrations and gatherings, the restaurant draws both locals and tourists. Happy hour offers a festive atmosphere complemented by views of passing yachts.
Piononos bakery, run by María Luisa Benavides, is renowned for its strawberry pavlova, a favorite among Key Biscayne’s residents. Its pastries are available for pickup and delivery throughout Miami-Dade and areas of Broward County, becoming a staple for birthdays and special occasions.
Lightkeepers at The Ritz-Carlton provides a sophisticated setting with varied dining options. From a laid-back brunch to a refined dinner featuring Mediterranean-inspired dishes, guests can enjoy meals in a breezy indoor-outdoor environment.
Gramps Getaway brings a slice of authentic Florida to Key Biscayne with its laid-back atmosphere and coastal cuisine. Known for fresh seafood, the restaurant adds a raw bar to its offerings, highlighting oysters from various regions.
La Boulangerie Boul’Mich is a low-key bakery combining French and Latin influences. Its diverse menu features items perfect for breakfast, with the croque madame on a baguette as a standout dish.
Boater’s Grill, nestled within Bill Baggs State Park, offers an open-air dining experience reminiscent of Old Miami. Serving Latin staples like ceviche and seafood paella, it provides an idyllic view of boats headed toward Stiltsville.
Novecento celebrates Argentine cuisine with a focus on meat and wine. The restaurant offers a broad menu, including sandwiches and seafood, ensuring a rich dining experience that satisfies carnivorous appetites.
Kebo Restaurant is a tapas haven favored by locals and tourists alike. Its atmosphere and paella dishes evoke a Madrid-like dining experience, making it a popular choice in Key Biscayne.
Costa Med Bistro + Wine presents a Mediterranean feast with an impressive wine list. From pasta to veal chops, the menu caters to those seeking classic European culinary delights.
Cantina Beach provides a casual Mexican dining option with stunning Atlantic views. Located at The Ritz-Carlton, its menu offers coastal Mexican dishes alongside refreshing ocean vistas.
Sir Pizza has been a go-to for Key Biscayne residents since 1969. Known for its nostalgic appeal, it continues to serve as the island’s top pizzeria, loved by families and sports teams alike.
Lastly, Donut Gallery Diner, despite relocating in 2023, maintains its reputation for classic breakfast fare. The Ted’s Special remains a valued dish among locals, solidifying its place in the community.
Key Biscayne’s restaurant scene is as varied as it is delightful, offering everything from elegant wine bars to inventive bakeries and classic diners. Whether you’re a local or a visitor making the short trip over the Rickenbacker Causeway, these culinary spots promise a taste of island life that is both memorable and savory.
